Please scroll down to see all the tables.
 
Intellectual Property: London Intellectual Property: Patent Litigation: London Recommended for Client Service
    Baker & McKenzieBerwin Leighton Paisner LLPBird & BirdFarrer & Co LLPFreshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLPK&L GatesMarks & Clerk Patent and Trade Mark AttorneysMishcon de ReyaOlswangPinsent MasonsPricewaterhouseCoopers Legal LLPRPC (Reynolds Porter Chamberlain LLP)Fox Williams Simmons & Simmons LLPSNR Denton
Recommended for Commercial Awareness
    Baker & McKenzieBerwin Leighton Paisner LLPBristowsDechert LLPDLA Piper UK LLPFarrer & Co LLPFasken Martineau LLPField Fisher Waterhouse LLPHogan LovellsMcDermott Will & Emery UK LLPMishcon de ReyaNabarro LLPReed Smith LLPTaylor Wessing LLP
 
Please scroll down to see all the tables.
 Intellectual Property: London
Intellectual Property: Patent Litigation: London
 

Intellectual Property : An Introduction

Contributed by Powell Gilbert LLP

IP litigation – UK court developments

A number of important developments took place in 2010/2011 in relation to the UK courts dealing with IP litigation.

The Patents Court continues to be extremely busy, with its lists dominated by disputes in the pharmaceutical, medical device and electronics sectors. Important cases heard during 2011 included Eli Lilly v Human Genome Sciences, the first patent case in the Supreme Court, in which the issue of industrial applicability was considered in the context of the biotechnology field. Also significant was Nokia v IPCOM, one of a large number of mobile telephony actions in which the concepts of patent infringement were applied to an industry built upon technical standards. There have also been numerous referrals to the Court of Justice of the European Union, including references in relation to SPCs - particularly for combination products - trade marks and copyright.

Key personnel changes took place in 2011: Lord Justice Jacob, the dominant figure in recent UK IP law, retired from the Court of Appeal in March 2011 to take up an academic role with UCL, following which Lewison J and Kitchin J were promoted from the High Court to the Court of Appeal.

Important reforms also came into effect in the Patents County Court (PCC), resulting in a revitalised and more affordable forum in which small and medium-sized enterprises can enforce their IP rights. The main changes are the introduction of hands-on case management – with procedural steps such as disclosure, witness statements and expert reports only being permitted if a cost-benefit test is satisfied – and caps on exposure to recoverable costs - £50,000 in total - and damages - £500,000. Spearheaded by an enthusiastic new judge, HH Judge Birss QC, formerly a specialist IP barrister, there has been a significant increase in the popularity of the PCC and it is clearly being recognised as appropriate for litigating certain types of IP cases.


Patent litigation in Europe

The CJEU was involved in patent issues in 2010/11, as decisions and AG opinions were provided in relation to a number of referrals from national courts in relation to Supplementary Protection Certificates, providing important clarification to the pharmaceutical industry regarding the proper basis for paediatric use extensions and combination products.

In addition, the CJEU gave its long-anticipated ruling regarding the proposed centralised European Patent Court. The ruling was negative, with the CJEU finding that a separate specialist patent court would be incompatible with the structures of the existing EU judicial framework.

Not to be dissuaded, however, member states pressed on, and further developed proposals for a ‘Unitary Patent’ under the ‘enhanced co-operation’ mechanism, which permits a sub-set of member states to progress measures even in the absence of full agreement. In a proposal supported by all member states except Italy and Spain, the Unitary Patent is a variation on the bundle of national patents granted by the EPO, and is envisaged to provide applicants with wholesale protection across all designated states, avoiding the need for national validation. The validity and infringement of such a Unitary Patent will then be determined centrally for all designated states.

Whilst the proposed framework for the Unitary Patent has garnered support, the method by which the rights granted by such patents will be enforced is not yet clarified. A Unified Patent Court existing separately from the EU is envisaged, but the proposals are at a relatively early stage and the detailed practical, procedural and political discussions are certain to continue in 2012.

Copyright

2010/11 was also a busy year in copyright law, with the UK Supreme Court giving its judgment in the Lucasfilm case, clarifying the nature of a work of “sculpture” and also confirming that the UK Court may exercise its jurisdiction to hear claims against UK-based parties alleged to infringe foreign copyright. The UK Courts also heard cases relating to online news-gathering services (Meltwater) and the question of whether ISPs can be required to block access to websites which make available infringing copies of copyrighted material (Newzbin).

Copyright issues were also on the agenda of the CJEU, with pending referrals expected to address questions regarding the Software Directive and the issue of copyright protection for computer programs and interfaces (SAS), and database protection in relation to football league fixture lists (Football Dataco).

Trade Marks

The CJEU gave its ruling in L’Oreal v eBay in relation to the liability of online marketplace operators for offers for sale placed on their websites regarding goods that infringe third-party trade marks. A key aspect was whether operators are protected by the E-Commerce Directive hosting defence. The CJEU held that this defence was not available to an operator taking an “active role” - e.g. by assisting in presentation or promotion - in respect of such infringing offers which gives the operator knowledge of, or control over, the data relating to the offers.

The CJEU also indicated that an operator would be liable if it was aware of facts or circumstances that would have led a diligent operator to realise that the infringing offers were unlawful and it did not promptly remove or disable access to them.

The English High Court will now apply the CJEU’s decision to the facts of the case, and it remains to be seen whether this decision will result in an effect upon online trading behaviour.

see more

Intellectual Property: London

Due to the number of tables in this section, the editorial is in alphabetical order by firm name.

This year we have added a new spotlight table highlighting leading law firms that employ patent agents and trade mark attorneys.

see more

This high-profile practice has a strong presence within both contentious and non-contentious IP. As sources have come to expect of a magic circle firm, Allen & Overy continues to attract instructions from some of the biggest names in the market. Highlights from the past year include advising eBay on a number of trade mark infringement claims and representing Research In Motion on patent dispute actions against Motorola.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Litigator Neville Cordell offers a broad range of IP expertise. Clients say he is "a pleasure to deal with, responsive and calm under pressure." Another source adds that he provides "clearly defined, commercially infused strategic advice." Colleen Keck jointly oversees the transactional work of the practice. Recent highlights include advising both a major pharmaceutical company on patent exploitation and a charitable organisation on a proposed language-training joint venture. Patent expert Nicola Dagg enjoys an outstanding reputation as a "smart and accomplished practitioner." She has been acting for market-leading aluminium recycler Aleris in a major patent infringement case. Sources feel that Huw Evans, who has played a key role in the firm's work with Research in Motion, also brings a great deal of expertise to the table.

Although this practice handles an array of work across the spectrum of IP, it boasts a particularly high level of expertise in handling patent litigation and other contentious concerns. It recently acted for Numatic International, the producer of the Henry vacuum cleaner, in relation to a passing-off issue. Other highlights include advising Aerocrine on the enforcement of nitric oxide testing technology patents.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Ian Kirby heads the practice and recently took the lead in advising easyGroup on the licensing of trade marks to easyJet. David Perkins is a highly regarded senior litigator whose expertise spans a range of patent work. Clients appreciate his "extensive experience and ability to see both the big picture and the little details."

Ashurst's IP team is widely known for its proactive approach to a range of non-contentious work. Members of the group recently advised on the IP elements of a number of significant transactions, including Apex Partners' USD830 million acquisition of Sophos, and Nordic Capital's acquisition of Britax.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Head of team Mark Lubbock principally advises on transactional matters. Clients admire him for his "insightful and highly practical advice."

This international firm maintains a strong non-contentious practice and continues to impress with the quality of its work and clientele. Recent highlights include negotiating sponsorship deals with two major English football clubs on behalf of Singha Beer. Clients appreciate the team's "proficient forward thinking and relationship-building skills."

Client Service "They are ideal for big clients that require swift replies. They anticipate what makes life easier for us."

Commercial Awareness "They have a sound grasp of all the key issues, including in niche areas, and can draft thorough responses to matters as they arise."

KEY INDIVIDUALS The experienced Michael Hart heads the team and is well regarded for the breadth of his knowledge base, whilst Paul Rawlinson is renowned for his "pragmatic business advice." He has been appointed to advise JCB on its global IP portfolio. Ben Allgrove continues to impress with his work for media organisations. Clients are confident that his "strong academic record" and "nose for the practical" will ensure his continuing rise. With a background in the commercial exploitation of IP rights, Michelle Blunt is appreciated by a client for her "willingness to go the extra mile in understanding us and tailoring her recommendations accordingly."

Sources confirm that Berwin Leighton Paisner continues to perform to a high standard, particularly in relation to soft IP work. A key client is the Financial Times, which instructed the team to act on a number of trade mark oppositions. Interviewees say that this "immensely confident" practice "maintains a good balance between ensuring we are comprehensively protected whilst working within a commercial timeframe."

Client Service "They respond swiftly and are always aware of how firm the ground is beneath us. They are never pushed into an unduly quick decision."

Commercial Awareness "They are very responsive, commercial and effective, and advise us very well on what are often complex processes."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Clark heads the department and continues to be heavily involved in the firm's work for the Newspaper Licensing Authority. Ian De Freitas is highly regarded for his work on a range of litigious concerns. Clients praise his "strategic decision-making" as well as his "timely delivery of the end product."

Viewed by sources as a stellar practice, this team boasts a deep bench and a long established reputation for quality. It has the expertise to advise on a broad array of both contentious and non-contentious concerns, making it a popular choice among market-leading clients. Highlights include acting for the FA on various trade mark infringements in the run-up to the World Cup, as well as assisting Nokia on patent actions throughout Europe. Clients are happy to report that "the team ticks every box in terms of service - brilliant lateral thinking, responsiveness and judgement."

Client Service "A friendly firm that is easy to deal with, down-to-earth and progressive. Not at all stuffy."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Peter Brownlow has an excellent reputation for his work relating to trade marks and copyright. Clients note that "he inspires a real sense of confidence." Katharine Stephens "knows her practice backwards," sources say, adding that she is "an efficient, sensible litigator." She has been heavily involved in much of the firm's contentious work. "Enthusiastic and switched-on," Jane Mutimear is deemed a talented IP litigator, whilst Rachel Fetches is seen as a talented associate who has contributed greatly to the team's work for Associated Newspapers and Actavis. Clients praise her proactive attitude and admire the way she "produces answers to questions that haven't even been asked yet." Trevor Cook remains a hugely respected and influential patent litigator. Clients note admiringly that "it's impossible to beat his understanding of the market - you'd have to travel far and wide to find something he doesn't know." The presence of joint practice head Morag Macdonald further bolsters the team's complement of outstanding patent litigators. She recently advised Norwegian oil service company EMGS on one patent dispute, and she is described by clients as "a hugely creative force." Interviewees praise patent litigator Neil Jenkins for his "sense of realism and skill in judging the merits of each case." Lorna Brazell is recognised for her continued representation of pharmaceutical companies in patent disputes, whilst Robert Williams led the team advising Synthon in High Court proceedings against Merz over an Alzheimer’s disease treatment. Mark Hilton advised Actavis on a major patent action in the High Court and the Court of Appeal, a reflection of his expertise and, according to sources, "the depth of his analysis and considerable scientific understanding."

This boutique firm maintains a steadfast foothold in London by advising a mix of clients on both contentious and non-contentious IP matters. Its diverse list of clients includes games developers, marketing companies and fashion houses, on behalf of which the group handles work ranging from commercial litigation to trade mark portfolio management.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Leading partner Margaret Briffa is acknowledged for her scope of expertise. Sources agree that her presence sets the tone for the quality of the firm's offering. Silas Brown continues to impress with his work, which is often highly technical in nature. He has a strong track record of acting in both trade mark and design rights infringement matters.

This full-service department maintains its position at the top of the sector, deploying a range of specialist expertise to good effect and advising high-profile clients on a range of significant issues. Clients admire the team's style, which is characterised as "firm and fair whilst avoiding unnecessary confrontation." Examples of its strengths include advising Siemens in multimillion-pound patent litigation, L'Oréal on its trade mark infringement action against eBay, and WPP over brand protection strategies.

Commercial Awareness "Their advice is always far from conservative thanks to the time they take to learn our business, sit in on strategy discussions and provide specially tailored direction."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Sally Field is trusted to act for pharmaceutical giants Smith & Nephew and AstraZeneca in key IP litigation. Clients highlight her "capacity to analyse technical and legal issues and put together a case that has a high chance of succeeding." Paul Walsh is singled out by sources as "easy to work with, bright and knowledgeable." Commentators report that Myles Jelf maintains "an excellent grasp of the technical aspects of cases, always taking the time to think clearly and logically." He is a key adviser to aerospace manufacturer Pratt & Whitney in patent litigation relating to Airbus A380 engines. Liz Cohen is building an excellent reputation for her focus on contentious concerns, especially in relation to matters arising in a healthcare context. She continues to advise Smith & Nephew in patent proceedings. Practice head Edward Nodder, meanwhile, has a hand in all of the firm's major pieces of patent litigation and continues to enjoy a high-flying reputation for his heavyweight expertise. According to sources, Brian Cordery combines a thorough understanding of brand management with "a vast reserve of experience" in patent litigation. He has been leading the charge in the team's counselling of marketing communications company WPP. Philip Westmacott is seen to possess strong patent litigation skills that have been well-harnessed by the likes of Smith & Nephew, whilst Alan Johnson is recognised as an accomplished practitioner whose "fantastic grasp of complex technical issues" marks him out. New partner James Boon is tipped by clients as a future star: "He is intelligent, hard-working and creative in analysing legal and technical problems."

CMS Cameron McKenna is able to draw on a wide-reaching network of European offices in bolstering the offering of its London-based IP practitioners. It is known for its work across a number of areas, including trade mark and design right infringement, litigation and drafting commercial agreements. Recent highlights include both a major trade mark clearance project for Colgate-Palmolive and advising Japan Tobacco International on a patent revocation action in the High Court.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Interviewees say Tom Scourfield is "responsive, practical and quick to provide us with ideas." Most recently he assisted the All England Lawn Tennis & Croquet Club in negotiating IP rights relating to the use of Wimbledon at the 2012 Olympics. Head of team Nick Beckett enjoys an excellent reputation in relation to patent litigation. He oversaw the group's input on the Japan Tobacco International litigation. Recent addition to the team Jeremy Morton is a TMT specialist with an excellent track record in IP work and a reputation as an "able and understanding" lawyer.

The team at Collyer Bristow is active across a sweep of IP concerns encompassing both litigious and transactional matters. Sources are particularly quick to recognise the group for its understanding of copyright, design right, trade mark and passing-off issues. Clients include Paul Smith, Play.com and Middlesex University.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Clients pinpoint Patrick Wheeler as having a "calm, fuss-free manner" that makes him "hugely easy to work with." He has been advising Boardman Bikes on the drafting of commercial agreements.

This well-regarded firm houses a team with a particularly strong track record among the media and fashion industries, drawing praise for its representation of clients on concerns spanning the length and breadth of IP law. Voices from the market praise the high quality of the team's drafting skills, as well as the way in which practitioners "always hit the ground running" in tackling any tricky problems. The team recently advised organic breakfast cereal company Rude Health Foods on brand protection issues.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Jim Dennis specialises in contentious matters and is praised by clients for his "quick response times and sound, practical advice." Adam Glass heads the team and is regularly instructed to handle a welter of IP issues. He recently advised shoe retailer Dune Group over a series of design right infringements.

Dechert's prominent global IP presence is increasingly reflected in the strengths of its thriving London practice. The team's expertise lies primarily in non-contentious work, as evidenced by its recent advice to Liz Earle Beauty over a partnership with Avon. Clients appreciate the way that practitioners "make complex issues easily understandable and give us the confidence that they have engaged clearly with all the issues."

Commercial Awareness "They're superb on both technical issues and in guiding us with general business counselling, not to mention great in negotiations."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Group head Paul Kavanagh "brings a vast amount of experience and a good commercial brain" to bear on his work in trade marks, design rights and copyrights.

This impressive team is known for its capacity to deal with a spectrum of concerns including patents, trade marks and design rights. Practitioners are instructed by clients drawn from a number of industries and can tap into the expertise of colleagues based in offices both overseas and across the UK. Clients say the firm is "highly responsive, commercially astute and on hand to provide advice at just the right time." It has been representing Honda in a parallel importation case and is assisting the FA Premier League in relation to the unauthorised use of satellite television viewing cards. The team's prominent standing is further reflected by its role in managing HSBC's global IP portfolio.

Commercial Awareness "They have a great understanding of our business and what we're trying to achieve, allowing them to better tailor their services to us."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Levine heads the firm's global IP and technology practice. He focuses on a range of copyright issues and was the main contact on the Honda parallel imports work. Clients say he is an ideal choice "when you need someone to weigh up all the variables and set the costs of legal action against the likely outcomes." Ruth Hoy commands a great level of expertise in trade mark and copyright matters. She impresses sources with her "technical prowess and first rate commercial acumen." Sian Croxon is known to clients as a "pragmatic, solutions-led and creative practitioner." She has played a key role in trade mark portfolio management for HSBC. Catherine Beloff is known as a "bright and practical" associate who is making a name for herself in the market. She has been an active participant in the team's work for Football DataCo over the copyrighting of football fixture lists. John Wilks is renowned for his track record in working for clients from the media sector. Clients say he can be "reliably trusted to handle whatever you throw at him."

This growing practice continues to impress with an offering that is "responsive, innovative and creative." The firm provides expert advice in trade mark and brand management issues for a spread of clients. High-profile names on its roster include MasterCard, Tumi and Xerox.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Group head John Olsen is a powerful draw card for clients who salute his "proactive approach" and "efforts in getting to understand our business."

Although Edwin Coe comes recommended for a wide array of IP matters, it is often best recognised for its advice on trade marks, copyright and design rights. It is particularly active in the technology, publishing and retail sectors, and earns admiration for its fast turnaround times. "When something needs doing they work very hard to make sure it gets done," states one interviewee. Clients include Datong and the World Wildlife Fund.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Miles oversees a broad ranging practice that recently led to him being instructed by the British Board of Film Classification in relation to a trade mark, copyright infringement and passing-off dispute with the Interactive Software Federation of Europe. He also advised JK Rowling's Lumos charity on trade mark clearance issues.

Farrer continues to build on its robust reputation in the cultural and charitable fields, handling IP issues on behalf of clients such as the National Gallery, Age UK and the Henley Royal Regatta. It is also increasingly visible in representing clients drawn from other sectors such as sporting, technology and media. Sources praise the group's ability to give "a succinct summary of our position," which is swiftly followed by "clear advice and instruction."

Client Service "They provide prompt, empathetic assistance."

Commercial Awareness "They are good at moulding raw legal advice and presenting it in a helpful way that enables us to make the correct decisions."

KEY INDIVIDUALS "Crystal clear communicator" Anthony Misquitta continues to shine in tackling IP litigation and licensing concerns. Clients say that he combines "sheer professionalism with a warm personality and solid understanding of the sector." Peter Wienand is known as a "commercially sensitive, efficient and pragmatic adviser" and heads the team to great effect. His clients include major organisations from across the sporting and cultural landscape.

Sources regard this team very highly for its handling of contentious and non-contentious matters. It earns high praise for its work in patent litigation, within which it represents notable clients such as Omnipharm. It has also recently advised the Construction Skills Certification Scheme on various domain name and trade mark disputes. 

Commercial Awareness "They have a comprehensive understanding of our status as a small company with a limited budget, shaping their service to fit our needs."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Ralph Cox is lauded for his thorough approach to patent litigation and strong standing among clients in the life science and hi-tech sectors.

Deemed to be a "well-informed and thorough" team with a strong line-up of IP specialists, Field Fisher Waterhouse has hitherto been best known for its strengths in trade marks, copyright and design rights. A programme for growth and the arrival of Mark Hodgson from Howrey now also underline its desire to expand on the patent litigation front, and the firm's international network increasingly allows it to take on work from a global clientele. Recent highlights include representing Google in High Court proceedings relating to its Adwords programme, as well as advising St Neots Packaging on a patent claim over cardboard sandwich packaging.

Commercial Awareness "They are highly business-oriented and prone to consider the commercial impact of the law rather than just talk about it."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Mark Holah is the firm's head of trade marks and brand protection. His high-profile clients include Marks & Spencer, Dell and FIFA, and he recently assisted Live Nation on IP issues arising from its acquisition of the Ticketmaster brand. Hamish Porter is valued for his talented litigation abilities and focus on trade mark infringement matters. Clients admire his "effectiveness in pulling together different strands of an argument to present a compelling case." Ian Craig has recently been part of a team handling Fabergé’s worldwide trade mark and design portfolio, whilst IP dispute resolution head Nick Rose specialises in the enforcement of trade marks, design rights and copyright. He counts Vestergaard Frandsen and the MCC amongst his clients. Rebecca Swindells specialises in contentious IP cases, handling disputes on behalf of clients across the media, sports and entertainment sectors. She also advises on anti-counterfeiting strategies. The addition of Mark Hodgson to the group is felt to be a real fillip to its patent litigation offering, whilst established litigator David Knight brings specialist expertise in technology-related matters.

This team is felt to be prospering across a wide array of soft IP matters that affect clients drawn from the media, fashion and cultural industries. It is well-equipped to handle both transactional and litigious issues for a list of clients that includes such names as CNN, Bloomberg and Monsoon Accessories. 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Clients single out the firm's head of IP and media, Robert Lands, as "clever, focused and to the point." He assisted PR firm Not Actual Size on image rights relating to a global advertising campaign for Aviva.

This impressive practice is singled out for its management of worldwide trade mark portfolios. In the last year it has advised Supergroup, owner of the Superdry Brand, on anti-infringement matters covering copyright, design rights and trade marks both in the UK and internationally. Clients are particularly enthusiastic about the team's service, noting that its lawyers are "always on the ball and there when you need them."

Client Service "A flexible group that remains absolutely focused on client needs."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Bennett oversees the work of the group and is known to sources as "approachable, practical and knowledgeable."

That Freshfields counts a number of major international brands among its clients is a mark of its standing in the market. Whilst the team draws on the resources of the wider firm when required, it also attracts complex work in its own right, and indeed takes the lead on major corporate transactions where IP is a major factor. An example of this was its involvement in Geely's acquisition of Volvo, a significant deal that hinged on the transfer of IP rights. Clients recommend the group "without reservation" both for "strategic legal advice and the delivery of results on time." 

Client Service "They impressed us with their excellent understanding of IP, their professional attitude and experience of working at an international level."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Avril Martindale was the lead partner on the Geely deal and is highly regarded for her expertise in acquiring and exploiting IP rights across a range of industries. Clients note that she is "passionately informed about her work and always goes the extra mile to help us." Justin Watts is known for his "sound judgement and ability to generate ideas at precisely the right time." He is a specialist in TMT and has been advising Sony on IP issues relating to its Playstation range. Chris Forsyth handles all enforcement for Yum! Restaurants in the UK, a portfolio that includes such brands as Pizza Hut and KFC. Clients appreciate his skill in "quickly assessing all the risks and providing us with accurate, useful advice."

Harbottle & Lewis specialises in handling a varied range of IP matters across the media and entertainment industries. The team acts for Lucasfilm, Orange and News International, and it counselled FIFA on brand protection issues at the football World Cup in South Africa. 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Practice head Mark Owen specialises in IP matters relating to digital media. Commentators say "he knows his area of the law inside-out," adding that he is "an absolute pleasure to deal with." Shireen Peermohamed wins acclaim for her "exceptional attention to detail" and a "gift for getting her points across succinctly."

This high-profile international firm houses a broad range of expertise that can be called on to deal with the full complement of IP concerns. Commentators claim that the practice is "going at full throttle" thanks to a burgeoning workload, where headline work includes advising Rockwool in a test-case trade mark dispute. With regards to patent litigation, Herbert Smith has been co-ordinating European-wide patent litigation on behalf of pharmaceutical client Eisai.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Solicitor advocate Mark Shillito oversees a varied practice and is pinpointed by sources for his "superbly commercial mind," whilst Joel Smith impresses with his "calm and collected approach" in both contentious and transactional circumstances. Nick Gardner heads the work of the group and applies his background in electronics and computing to good effect in complex technical disputes. Commentators highlight him as "sensible, pragmatic and forever striving to achieve the right result." Sophie Rich combines a focus on patent litigation with her role as leader of the firm's life sciences group. Her work with Daiichi Sankyo on patent litigation relating to the antibiotic Levofloxacin provides a measure of how she synergises her two roles. David Wilson remains a much sought-after patent litigator, as does Sebastian Moore, who is known to clients for his "tactical foresight." He can call on a background in chemistry when tackling complicated IP disputes.

Hogan Lovells generates praise for blending a global focus with in-depth expertise across the full spectrum of IP concerns. In addition to the presence of an array of sector specialists, the team is also able to draw upon the expertise of the wider firm. Recent highlights include managing Skype's global trade marks portfolio, advising PepsiCo/Frito-Lay on the exploitation and protection of its UK trade marks and representing John Lewis in a furniture design infringement action. 

Commercial Awareness "They have a deeply grounded knowledge of our industry which makes a huge difference to how they advise us."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Louise Zafer advises Play.com on trade mark opposition issues and has an excellent reputation for brand-related work. Clients note that her advice is "well considered and presents us with all the options, yet she lets us know which she thinks is the best route to pursue." David Latham is an experienced senior figure who commands a fine trade marks practice. "He excels in orchestrating the best way of responding to events as they happen," sources claim. Now a consultant, Nicholas Macfarlane is deemed a distinguished patent litigator whose expertise spans a number of industries. Head of team Robert Anderson demonstrates real skill in handling complex patent litigation, according to sources, as underlined by his representation of Hollister in a series of high-profile disputes. Fellow patent litigator Stephen Bennett has been a key figure in the firm's work for mobile phone manufacturer HTC, whilst Adam Cooke impresses clients with the way in which he "rolls his sleeves up, gets out there and gets stuck in."

This practice is geared towards conducting patent litigation for a varied assortment of clients. It is experienced in advising companies from the software, energy and medical device sectors, generating recognition for its skill in "getting up to speed quickly with the problems faced by clients and providing sound, clear advice."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Head of department Alastair McCulloch is known to sources as an "even-keeled character" in facing down patent litigation challenges arising across a range of industries.

K&L Gates has developed a well-rounded and regarded London practice that offers a particularly strong understanding of soft IP concerns. Major international clients include AOL, Puma and Time Warner, and the team handles trade mark and brand protection issues in the UK for WWE. Sources commend the group for its communication skills and "knack for guiding lay people through complex issues."

Client Service "They take a common sense approach that fits strongly with the way we work."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Dominic Bray heads the team and is most widely recognised for his understanding of the protection and exploitation of IP rights. Clients indicate that he is "quiet, thoughtful and extensively experienced, with as much of an eye for commercial issues as for legal constraints." Rebecca Halford-Harrison is identified as the firm's key contentious expert and is hugely popular with clients, one of whom commends her as both "a lateral thinker and a first-class litigator."

This practice continues to consolidate an already strong reputation with clients for its work on commercial IP matters, particularly in relation to the protection and exploitation of rights. It acts for market-leading brands such as Orange, Expedia and LOVEFiLM International, and has also been advising shipping broker Clarksons on intellectual property concerns. Clients are highly enthusiastic about the quality of service the firm offers, noting that "we would like to see more Kemp Littles in the market: they always have their priorities in the right order, get to the point quickly and offer commercially sound advice." 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Head of team Paul Garland is known to interviewees as "an astute practitioner with a succinct style." He recently advised the Sumitomo Corporation on patent and regulatory issues pertaining to the commercial exploitation of a new product.

This global firm is increasingly making waves in the UK for its handling of both contentious and non-litigious IP concerns. The London-based team has recently been involved in work to develop the IP environment in Abu Dhabi, a project that it is handling alongside a slew of day-to-day instructions in respect of patent, trade mark and design right infringements.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Larry Cohen is a widely admired IP litigator who, according to sources, remains hungry for high-quality work. In recent times he has been active in disputes across a variety of industries including pharmaceuticals and financial services, and has also played a key role in the firm's work in Abu Dhabi. Gail Crawford specialises in non-contentious concerns and is appreciated by clients for her "quietly diligent, yet firm" approach. They claim she is a "solidly practical lawyer - not one to posture or bang tables."

Several of the Laytons team have expertise and qualifications in the sciences, which allows the firm to advise clients on complex technical issues as well as brand protection and other soft IP areas. The well-respected group also handles exploitation of IP rights for companies and organisations from a range of industries.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Esther Gunaratnam continues to impress with her work on brand protection and other commercial IP matters. She has a background in electrical engineering that helps add another dimension to her practice.

Lewis Silkin is known for its work in the media and marketing sectors, and in IP matters its strengths lie very much in brand management. The team's major clients include high-profile international organisations, which also call upon it to handle a range of trade mark-related work. On the domestic front, a recent highlight saw the team acting for the AA in a comparative advertising dispute with Green Flag. 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Chapman, who is noted by clients as "informed and easy to work with," has a terrific reputation for contentious IP work. He focuses on brand protection and the enforcement of trade marks and design rights. Giles Crown has a reputation as a "practical, user-friendly" solicitor with great expertise in his field. He heads the team and has a particular focus on advertising and marketing.

This practice offers the high-quality service expected of a magic circle law firm, handling a diverse range of soft and hard IP issues with a strong focus on commercial disputes. In recent times it has acted on significant pieces of work for the likes of easyGroup, Tate & Lyle and William Hill. Clients say the team has the capacity "to weigh up our place in the market and offer advice that speaks directly to our most pressing concerns."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Sources note that solicitor advocate Benedict Bird impresses as "someone who can be counted on if a dispute reaches the courtroom." He focuses on IP matters affecting the financial services sector, and has advised some of the biggest names in that field. Fellow litigator Ian Karet is known for providing "resourceful, thorough advice and in-depth assistance." He was a central figure in the team's work on negotiating a settlement between easyGroup and easyJet following their high-profile rights dispute. Nigel Jones is, according to clients, "knowledgeable yet down-to-earth; really helpful and able to collaborate with us effectively." He specialises in patent litigation, recently advising Johnson & Johnson subsidiary Janssen-Cilag on a dispute with Bayer Healthcare.

Macfarlanes concentrates on handling disputes relating to trade marks, licensing and passing off. Its clients are drawn from an eclectic mix of industries and include well-known brands such as Red Bull, Reebok and Universal Music. The team has been continuing to assist Anheuser-Busch over the Budweiser trade mark, questions relating to which have now been referred to the ECJ.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Geoff Steward heads the group and is known for his "detailed grasp" of contentious IP concerns. He has acted for Umbro in a number of licensing disputes.

This innovative practice is traditionally best known for its work in the patent litigation sphere, but it is increasingly a noted presence in soft IP as well. Solicitors are able to draw on the expertise of the firm's associated patent and trade mark attorneys practice, a factor that is noted by clients as greatly influential in deciding to instruct the team. Clients appreciate the firm's style, saying that "it is sensitive to our perspective and receptive to our ideas."

Client Service "It feels like they are part of our in-house team. We really value their collegial approach and support."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Gregor Grant is considered a talented patent litigator with an excellent reputation in the field. He works across a range of technologies, and recently advised leading medical device manufacturer Occlutech on an infringement issue. William Cook is known to sources as a thoughtful and knowledgeable practitioner. He acted for Virgin Media on a patent dispute over the technology behind electronic TV guides. Mike Gilbert wins plaudits for his patent litigation work, although he is also familiar to clients for being able to advise on soft IP matters. He was instructed by investment management services provider BlackRock on a significant trade mark infringement and passing-off dispute.

Mayer Brown is known for delivering high-quality IP advice and has the capacity to tackle the concerns of a range of clients. It is, however, particularly well known for its trade mark and patent work for clients in the financial services and life sciences sectors. A recent highlight saw the team assisting in a novel deal allowing the National Stock Exchange of India to distribute the Dow Jones and S&P 500 indices in real time. Impressed interviewees describe the team's lawyers as "forthcoming, helpful and able to provide interesting solutions to tricky problems."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Sarah Byrt has a wealth of expertise in handling transactional IP matters and routinely works alongside the firm's corporate group in providing advice to high-profile clients. Jonathan Radcliffe recently joined the firm from Nabarro LLP. He is described as "communicative, thorough and helpful." 

This team impresses the market with its understanding of a number of industry sectors, most notably life sciences and digital media. Clients speak highly of the way in which members of the team "set extremely high standards for themselves, yet are skilled at quickly transforming ideas into practical applications." Its wide-ranging expertise covers all areas of soft and hard IP, and one recent highlight saw the firm assist online casino 32Red in a trade mark infringement dispute with William Hill.

Commercial Awareness "They have shone in providing practical advice that enables us to determine the risks involved in any action."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Hiroshi Sheraton is a contentious IP expert with a strong track record in both trade mark and patent work. He recently advised Absolut in a dispute over the rebranding of Virgin Radio as Absolute Radio. Rohan Massey is ranked for the first time this year on the back of his excellent reputation in the commercialisation of IP. Clients appreciate his straightforward approach, which is described as "to the point and business-focused; he combines a brief overview with sound advice, not reams of legal opinions."

This firm has an excellent reputation for handling soft IP work, with the team routinely instructed to deal with complex contentious issues involving trade marks and design rights. Clients are hugely impressed with the group's work and speak highly of the approach taken by individual members of the team and by the wider practice. In the past year the team has dealt with disputes arising across a variety of industries and sectors. It includes among its clientele international brands such as Gucci, Mitre and Microsoft.

Client Service "They don't wait for us to call them if an important issue arises, which makes a huge difference to our operations."

Commercial Awareness "They are very commercial in the way they go about things, putting our business needs ahead of legal jargon. They understand that the law can be a vehicle for helping us capitalise on an opportunity."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Tracey possesses a strong track record in trade mark, passing-off and design rights work. Clients know him as "a multi-dimensional lawyer with an impressively broad set of skills." Martyn Hann is known for his fine performances in relation to both contentious and non-contentious work. He recently advised Carbon Fibre Preforms over a complex patent application matter. Department head Jeremy Hertzog is deemed a senior and respected figure within the firm, with clients stating their admiration for the way he sets the tone for the work of the team. Adam Morallee is an expert in design rights, copyright and trade marks. Sources appreciate his "willingness to encourage creativity whilst keeping clients aware of the surrounding legal contexts."

The variety of work handled by this impressive team means it is marked out by clients as one to watch. Solicitors are well equipped to handle the full spectrum of IP work, from trade mark filings and brand protection advice to complex patent litigation. The firm handles Levi Strauss & Co's UK trade mark infringement work and has recently been instructed by the makers of soft drink Big Red over a dispute with Red Bull. It has also advised ratiopharm on the launch of a major pharmaceutical product.

Commercial Awareness "They combine an impressive range of subject matter expertise and legal excellence with the ability to understand and help us achieve our business goals."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Eesheta Shah is new to the firm's partnership and to the rankings, and comes with a good track record in soft IP. Clients praise her common sense approach and are keen to tip her for the top. David Parrish has been highly active in trade mark portfolio and brand protection work for such big-ticket clients as Twitter and Samsonite.

Clients note that Olswang excels in "helping us take control of the full range of market opportunities." It is best known for its media work, which translates in the IP sphere to a practice that is strong in soft IP and increasingly strong on the patent litigation side as well. It is able to supplement its offering thanks to the expertise of a team of patent attorneys, providing clients with an impressively well-rounded service. The team acted for Absolute Radio in the dispute over its name and recently advised medical devices company Kinetic Concepts in high-value patent litigation.

Client Service "They are reliable, speedy and good at taking into account what's being asked of them."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Helen Newman handles a range of contentious and non-contentious soft IP work, and recently advised the charity Elephant Family on the IP elements of its London Elephant Parade campaign. Clients admire the way she "applies practical and sensible advice so as to improve the value of our brand." Joel Barry is popular among clients who deem him "effective" and "able to understand our needs." He has an impressive soft IP practice and is a trusted adviser to Sky. Joint head of group Paul Stevens has led the team's work on many of its high-profile cases over the past year. Clients single him out as "personable, easy to understand and quick to return our queries." Stephen Reese has an excellent reputation for work across the IP sphere, particularly in relation to life sciences matters. He recently assisted Convergence Pharmaceuticals in a major IP-affected acquisition. Assisting him in leading the work of the group is Michael Burdon, who is identified as an experienced patent litigator. He headed the team that counselled Kinetic Concepts. Meanwhile, Campbell Forsyth continues to impress with his "detailed and creative approach" to litigation.

Osborne Clarke employs a strong and increasingly prominent team that has the capacity to deal with matters across the IP spectrum. Clients pay tribute to the "timely and collaborative" style of the team and praise the technical expertise on offer within the group. Recent highlights include advising Marks & Spencer in a widely-reported Google Adwords dispute with Interflora, a case that interviewees feel is set to have an important impact on the use of trade marks.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Theo Savvides heads the department and has an excellent reputation for contentious IP advice. Clients say he is "a highly bright and capable guy who gives you meaningful advice in plain English." Another source said Savvides "astounds us with his understanding of complex technical details."

Pinsent Masons has long impressed in soft IP but is now also felt to be establishing a strong presence in patent litigation, particularly for acting on behalf of clients from the pharmaceutical industry. It remains strong in trade mark matters, recently defending Asda against accusations of infringing the Specsavers brand in a comparative advertising campaign. Clients speak highly of "the time they spend getting to know us, our work and our needs" and are quick to praise the team for its grasp of complex details.

Client Service "They are nimble, flexible and make the effort to tailor their approach to each dispute."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Iain Connor is one of the team's standout individuals and earns recognition for the quality of his advice. He recently assisted 123 Närhmittel in an infringement dispute concerning its edible Yummy Dough, which Hasbro contended is damaging to its Play Doh mark. Rebecca Mitton is seen by sources as a talented associate who has played a key role in much of the firm's contentious work in recent times, whilst patent litigator Clare Tunstall is felt to have been central to the firm's increasing profile and capability. Tom Cahill continues to impress commentators with his work on pharmaceutical-related contentious IP instructions.

Research confirms that this firm has a solid practice with an emphasis on acting for the sports and entertainment industries. The team oversees the management of trade mark portfolios belonging to organisations such as Clear Channel, Ascot Racecourse and the England and Wales Cricket Board, and advised Live Nation on the IP elements of its Heroes Concert at Twickenham.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Head of department Jeremy Summers earns resounding endorsements from clients for coupling a "personable style with supreme organisational skills."

This renowned boutique continues to expand beyond its traditional strengths in patent litigation, helping to build its reputation on soft IP matters. One highlight of the past year saw the group advising Nokia on an infringement dispute with Apple relating to smartphone technology. It also won instructions to deal with a range of trade mark concerns for Procter & Gamble, taking in such brands as Gillette, Duracell and Pantene. Clients say the firm's solicitors are "smart, strategic and friendly."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Ayrton enjoys a broad-ranging practice that covers trade mark and patent work across a number of industries. Sources commend him for "thinking outside the box and providing commercially savvy solutions." Penny Gilbert is an expert in the biotech sector and is viewed as one of the most respected patent litigators in the market.  Interviewees are full of praise for leading practitioner Tim Powell. He impresses clients with his grasp of technical details and an ability to "find the best route through complicated situations." Zoë Butler is a patent litigator who is sought out to advise on a range of technologies. Clients identify her scientific background, years of experience and grasp of detail as among the main factors ing her success. Ari Laakkonen has a specialist interest in electronics and IT-related IP matters, playing a key role in the firm's work for such clients as the Kaneka Corporation and ERGO Versicherungsgruppe.

Commended for its commercial approach, this practice enjoys a ranking this year thanks to the excellent strength of feedback from the market. It specialises in the protection and exploitation of IP rights, including recent work for such high-profile organisations as Northern & Shell and Taylor Wimpey. Clients enjoy the way the team provides legal advice that is "personalised, direct and responsive."

Client Service "Their overall delivery of service is very prompt. They give clear feedback, speak in terms we can understand and allow us to make the final decisions."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Latika Sharma heads the team and handles soft IP issues for a range of household name clients. Commentators say she is "adept at boiling down complex situations to the fundamental issues."

This boutique IP firm has a great reputation thanks to its winning instructions from such international names as Thermos and GlaxoSmithKline, and the team is trusted to handle significant issues across a range of technical specialisms. Commentators declare their confidence in a team that is "fantastically easy to work with and able to tailor its efforts quickly to dealing with each particular case."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Sara Ashby is a contentious specialist with an excellent track record across an array of IP work. Interviewees describe her as "incredibly tenacious, bright and able to turn her hand to the subject in question very quickly." Charters Macdonald-Brown is known as "a meticulous lawyer with an understanding of how to overcome technical barriers." He is held in high regard by the market and is considered to be a driving force behind the firm's success. Simon Chalkley specialises in commercial IP matters, as demonstrated by his recent transactional assistance to computer games publisher Square Enix. Sources say he is "a thoroughly reliable practitioner" who "tells it like it is." Anna Carboni joins from Powell Gilbert. She is an expert in trade marks and is viewed as one of the most respected IP litigators in the market.

This team boasts the experience, strength in depth and capacity to handle a broad range of IP work. Clients include Channel 4, Nike and Microsoft, with commentators listing the qualities of the firm as "supportive, client-focused and hard working." The traditional media focus that has propelled Reed Smith to its current prominence is gradually expanding to include clients in the retail, travel and IT sectors.

Commercial Awareness "They really understand us as a business. It's brilliant to be able to talk to them without re-hashing our needs, saving us time and money."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Michael Skrein is seen by market sources to be central to much of the high-profile work that passes through the department. Clients say he is both "piercingly astute and a powerful negotiator," and underline the sense of confidence he brings to the table. Stephen Edwards is an impressive copyright specialist who has strong expertise in the field of broadcasting. He has recently advised the BBC and the European Broadcasting Union on reforms to copyright law that affect the availability of programming. Emma Lenthall impresses sources with the depth and breadth of her experience, and is praised as an individual who "knows the answer before you've asked the question." She jointly oversees the work of the department along with Carolyn Pepper, who principally deals with soft IP concerns but also has experience of complex technical disputes. Louise Berg is building a reputation in the market thanks to her organisational skills and knack for remaining "level headed and unflustered under pressure."

Although Rouse Legal boasts an integrated set-up that allows it to take advantage of its international presence in jurisdictions such as India and China, the team in London often takes centre stage in its operations. Major clients include GlaxoSmithKline, Google and Harley Davidson, underlining the team's work for a diverse range of sectors and emphasising the breadth of its expertise. Commentators note that the firm employs a talented group of associates and "does well in pulling together information from different areas to provide consolidated advice."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Managing partner Karen Fong enjoys an outstanding reputation for dispute resolution across a range of soft and hard IP matters, and regularly advises high-profile clients on such issues. Jeremy Newman continues to impress with his work on enforcement issues, particularly within the TMT sector. He has played a key role in advising on Nokia's UK anti-counterfeiting programme. Tony Willoughby remains a guiding light within the practice and has conducted litigation for such notable brands as Diageo. Clients say that "it's comforting to have someone with such great experience and knowledge on board." Arty Rajendra specialises in trade mark and patent disputes and has an established reputation as an "efficient, careful and thoughtful operator." Life sciences expert Diana Sternfeld wins instructions thanks to her track record as a successful patent litigator, whilst experienced practitioner Richard Willoughby has expertise across a range of scientific disciplines.

Reynolds Porter Chamberlain has channelled its IP resources into servicing the media, sports and retail sectors. It boasts an enviable client list that includes such major brands as Dunlop, HMV and Bloomsbury Publishing. Recent highlights include advising Sports Direct on complex litigation relating to its Lonsdale brand and acting for the Copyright Licensing Agency on enforcement strategies.

Client Service "They're excellent to work with. They have a good understanding of how we work and what our priorities are, providing focused advice in the format we like to receive it." 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Jeremy Drew heads the team and was the lead partner on the work for Sports Direct. Clients describe him as "thorough and proactive, with bags of flair." Clive Thorne has become an integral part of the team since his arrival, recently advising Comvita on its trade mark infringement strategy. David Cran is praised for his methodical approach to trade mark matters that has lent itself well to his work for lastminute.com.

The team at Simmons & Simmons is admired for its patent litigation work although it is increasingly deemed to be a substantial force in soft IP too. Interviewees describe the service they receive from the team as excellent, an observation that is reinforced by a client list that includes British American Tobacco, English National Ballet and Hugo Boss. Recent highlights include advising Genmab on a research and licensing agreement, CoreValve in a patent dispute, and the NSPCC over the protection of its trade marks.

Client Service "This is a firm that is very mindful of its clients' time. Highly efficient."

KEY INDIVIDUALS David Stone is a soft IP specialist with an excellent track record in trade mark matters and design law. Clients say he is "a delight to work with, succinct and forever available." Kevin Mooney continues to impress with his success across a broad sweep of IP matters. His expertise is increasingly acknowledged by regulatory bodies and he is also a key adviser to the European Commission. Sources deem Rowan Freeland an "astute, thoughtful and incisive" patent litigator. He is known for his work in the life sciences sector, where he advises the likes of GlaxoSmithKline and sanofi-aventis. As with a number of his colleagues, Marc Döring is active across a range of industries. Clients note that he is "the ideal solicitor: able to manage a case effectively, use his time wisely and hit deadlines."

This impressive firm continues to feature prominently in representing clients from a variety of industry sectors. High-profile clients include Nintendo, Sanofi-Aventis and Ladbrokes, and the team works closely with colleagues in the firm's German office to provide a joined-up international service. Commentators praise the team for its efficiency and are quick to highlight the expertise of London-based practitioners in acting on both domestic and cross-border instructions. 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Ray Black is noted by clients for his leadership skills and grasp of strategy. He has a broad-ranging practice that covers IP work of all types. Commercially-minded practitioner David Rose heads the practice and specialises in patent litigation, though he is also active on the soft side of IP. Recently he advised JVC on a parallel import case. 

The IP practice at Slaughter and May undertakes work of both a commercial and transactional nature, as well as a number of contentious cases. Solicitors have excelled in acting for the firm's long list of notable clients in addition to attracting work on a standalone basis. Recent highlights include advising Arsenal FC on an array of IP matters and assisting online retailer Ocado on an audit of its IP rights. 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Cathy Connolly is an established specialist in IP transactional work and has an excellent reputation amongst clients for her support in major deals. Susie Middlemiss heads the department and acts on both commercial matters and litigation. She recently advised Heals on a complex IP dispute. David Ives is known for his commercial IP work, especially those matters with a strong IT angle.

This high-quality team encompasses expertise on both the soft and hard sides of IP and is able to offer clients a high level of technical know-how. Sources point out that this equips it with a particular advantage when dealing with the complex patent litigation matters that have become a staple of the group. The team has also won the approval of the market for combining a logical approach with a hard-hitting style.

Client Service "They have an impressive ability to simplify matters and make them clear to the inexperienced client."

KEY INDIVIDUALS John Linneker is known for his substantial litigation practice and recently advised metal and plastic product manufacturer Schütz in a technically complex dispute. His colleague Anthony Trenton acted for Musion Systems in a dispute over the technology used in the projection of 3D images at pop concerts. Clients admire his "ability to understand relationships with us and distil from those the correct amount of information needed."

Seen by interviewees as a capable and client-oriented team, this two-partner setup enjoys admiration from across the board. Sources are especially keen to state their appreciation of the team's expertise on soft IP issues. The practice acts for such well-known brands as Munich Re, Richemont and Elle Macpherson, and it recently helped inventor Michael Pritchard in commercially exploiting his creations.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Alexander Carter-Silk heads the department and is known across the market as a "personable, enthusiastic and hard-working" solicitor with great expertise in trade mark and brand management issues.

Stephenson Harwood continues to assist such high-profile clients as SAB Miller, Birds Eye and Gap on IP matters, and played a key role in BTG's takeover of publicly held company Biocompatibles. It houses a breadth of expertise to assist clients on IP disputes and commercial transactions alike. Clients are enthusiastic in their praise of the group, claiming that "it's reassuring to know you can pick up the phone and they will be there to provide timely and sound advice."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Lucy Harrold heads the team and has established a good reputation in resolving contentious IP concerns. Eifion Morris advises on both contentious and transactional concerns, recently assisting Datacard Corporation on a High Court patent and trade mark infringement action. Commentators note his ability to maintain "an easy-going approach with clients and a bulldog style with the opposition."

This practice has the breadth and depth to handle a broad mixture of work, combining experience in complex scientific and technical work with a thorough understanding of brand management. Notable clients include Burberry, Toyota and Hewlett-Packard, underlining the diversity of its client list. Commentators are unstinting in their praise of the team, labelling its management of trade mark portfolios as particularly outstanding: "Far from being a factory, their specialists help to generate outcomes that are of the very highest quality."

Commercial Awareness "They are hugely knowledgeable about the issues we face and we know they don't have to learn things from scratch."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Roland Mallinson is familiar to the market as a superb practitioner who is "committed to client care and delivers quality of the highest order in all he does." He has broad-reaching experience and is active across both contentious and non-contentious matters. Jason Rawkins advises household names such as PepsiCo and Visa on trade mark and design rights issues. Clients appreciate that he is "readily available, constructive and sensitive to the demands of our business." James Marshall is lauded for a "sensible approach" to patent litigation that delivers results. He recently defended Generics UK in an infringement suit brought by Cephalon. Simon Cohen heads up the patent litigation team and draws successfully on his scientific background to advise clients in the pharmaceutical sector. Up and coming partner Christopher Thornham recently joined the firm from SJ Berwin. He is best known for his patent litigation work.

This highly regarded team is best known for its contentious work on trade marks and design rights for substantial international clients such as BMW, Jaeger and Tesco. The firm has long acted for consumer rights organisation Which on licensing matters, including recently advising on obtaining a High Court injunction following the leaking of extracts from a restaurant guide.

KEY INDIVIDUALS "Prompt and logical" Michael Gardner boasts a highly admired contentious IP practice. Sources say "he makes things clear and helps us to understand the law from within a business context."

Wiggin focuses its efforts on soft IP work with a particular emphasis on the media sector. It handles both litigation and commercial matters, and is known for its work with both US film companies and UK-based media organisations. Highlights include advising Virgin Media on a series of criminal IP enforcement matters and assisting Columbia Pictures with trade mark pre-clearance issues related to film production. 

KEY INDIVIDUALS Simon Baggs heads the team and is considered central to both its work and reputation. He is flagged by sources as a "strategically clever and calm litigator who will always look for the best possible resolution for clients."

With a principal focus on contentious concerns this group acts for clients from an interesting mix of industries, the roster including such names as EMI, Renault F1 and Macmillan Cancer Care. Practitioners are also able to call upon the assistance of colleagues from throughout the firm's international network to handle cross-border work. A key highlight saw the team in London work with the Milan office to assist the Cipriani group of companies in a passing-off dispute.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Tim Bamford is positively received by the market for his involvement in resolving IP disputes. He recently defended Roquette against an application by Tate & Lyle to revoke a patent for an artificial sweetener.

The team's dividing its time between the firm's two UK offices means it can be regarded as a strong metropolitan presence and an exceptional regional outfit. Clients value the solicitors' focus on building relationships, and this enthusiasm is reflected in the number of high-profile organisations the firm advises across the full spectrum of IP concerns. Highlights of the past year include advising Unilever on attempts by the BNP to use an image of the Marmite jar in a 2010 election video, and representing Birds Eye in a trade mark dispute with Northern Foods.

KEY INDIVIDUALS Patrick Duxbury heads the life sciences team and is noted for his involvement in a good slice of the firm's IP work. He specialises in transactional and licensing work, generally on behalf of major pharmaceutical clients. David Barron has a reputation as a "shrewd and thoughtful" litigator with a commercial mindset and expertise in the hi-tech sector. As head of the IP team, Gordon Harris has a reputation as a vastly experienced litigator. Premium Aircraft Interiors Group sought his counsel in a dispute with Virgin Atlantic Airways over the patent for a business class aircraft seat. Paul Inman joins the team from Howrey and is set to boost the patent litigation offering of the team with his many years of expertise.

Robin Fry of DAC Beachcroft LLP is an acclaimed copyright specialist who acts for clients drawn from a variety of industries. Sources say that he "gets to the point, gives clear opinions and always produces the information you need when you need it." David Hansel of Hansel Henson LLP is an experienced practitioner with a forensic approach and congenial style, according to sources. He specialises in soft IP and advises the sandwich chain Subway on its UK trade mark issues. Peter Taylor of Baker Botts UK LLP is known as an exceptionally bright litigator whose work on the enforcement of IP rights continues to impress. His high-profile clients include the LEGO Group and Calloway Golf Company. Jonathan Ball of Norton Rose LLP is an expert in contentious IP who is singled out by clients for his results-oriented approach. He is noted for his work in the pharmaceutical and engineering sectors, and has been increasingly active on brand management matters. Dennis Lee has joined Michelmores from Silverman Sherliker. He works with clients on a wide variety of IP issues with a particular emphasis on the creative industries. Commentators are impressed with the quality of his advice and his leadership of the firm's IP offering. From his position within the firm's clean technology team, Richard Penfold of Brown Rudnick LLP handles a range of IP protection and exploitation work across the media and hi-tech industries. Simon Stokes heads Blake Lapthorn's IP presence in London and turns his attention to non-contentious matters on behalf of clients across a range of sectors including the publishing, education and financial services. Ian Wood recently arrived at Charles Russell LLP from Mayer Brown and is considered by the market to be a useful addition to its IP offering thanks to his expertise in protection, enforcement and exploitation proceedings. Simon Gallant of Gallant Macmillan LLP is new to the IP rankings and arrives with a terrific reputation for brand management and other soft IP work. Sources note his "great personal rapport with his client base, a human approach to stressful situations and an ability to explain things in a simple manner." Caroline Hayward of Trowers & Hamlins LLP is another new addition to the table. She is a specialist in soft IP and has an impressive track record in copyright, trade mark and design rights work for a healthy mix of clients. Commentators appreciate her availability and praise her combination of "intellectual capacity" and "commercial practicality." John Hull of Memery Crystal LLP has significant expertise in the sphere of soft IP, including recently advising Brunel University on a potential infringement of a trade mark by Thames Valley University. Clients describe him as "low key and precise; a strategic thinker rather than a table-pounder." Georgie Collins of Lawrence Graham LLP was promoted to the firm's partnership last year and continues to lead the IP group with aplomb. Clients say she is a "communicative, able and patient" solicitor who has enjoyed success in both contentious and non-contentious work. Denzil Gunner of Atkins Thomson attracts praise from clients for his brand management work. Commentators say his style is relaxed but firm, and say the way "he always has everything under control inspires full confidence in his abilities." Richard Price of Winston & Strawn is a new arrival from Taylor Wessing and comes with a wealth of experience. He is a much-admired patent litigator who remains active across a range of sectors. Ian Starr of D Young & Co is a hugely knowledgeable IP litigator whose move from Ashurst has been the talk of the market. He handles the protection and enforcement of IP rights on behalf of clients from the pharmaceutical, FMCG and broadcasting sectors. Vanessa Marsland of Clifford Chance LLP boasts a great track record in substantial trade mark, copyright and patent issues. Clients admire her fluency with both commercial and contentious issues and say "she gives exceptional advice on sensitive, high-value matters." Paul Harris of Gowlings handles both contentious and non-contentious IP work. Clients note that he "not only understands the basics, but looks at things through a businessman's eyes and takes into account not just the law, but commercial considerations as well." Gary Moss recently joined EIP. He is widely noted as an experienced patent litigator. He has recently been heavily involved in supplementary protection certificate work. Neil Coulson of Baker Botts UK LLP is an able patent litigator with an excellent reputation in the field. Interviewees single him out as "methodical, searching and detailed both in the questions he asks and the answers he gives." Nikki Powell has joined Addleshaw Goddard LLP from Edwin Coe. She is building an excellent reputation for patent-related work in the TMT sector. Clients are impressed with how "she keeps things understandable and focused on what we want to achieve."

Future Events 

6th June: Chambers USA General Counsel Seminar: New York

7 June 2012: Chambers USA Awards for Excellence 2012, New York




7 June 2012: Launch of Chambers USA 2012


17 September 2012: Chambers Latin America Awards for Excellence 2012, Miami


25 October 2012: Chambers Bar Awards 2012

 

Chambers News

10 May 2012: Chambers Europe Awards for Excellence, Amsterdam