South Africa : An Introduction

Contributed by ENS (Edward Nathan Sonnenbergs)

The recent trend in the South Africa regulatory environment has seen the emergence of increasing policy and regulation pertaining to the telecommunications, media, broadcasting and information technology sectors (collectively the “ICT sector”) in South Africa, in an attempt to bring South African ICT law in line with international trends and practice. This advancement is set to continue, with future legislative amendments and policy implementation expected to have a far-reaching impact on the future regulatory landscape of the ICT sector in South Africa.

Telecommunications and broadcasting 

Telecommunications and broadcasting services are regulated by the Independent Communications Authority of South Africa ("ICASA"), with the primary piece of legislation governing these two sectors being the Electronic Communications Act, 2005 (the “ECA”). The main policy imperative underlying the ECA is the introduction of a more flexible regulatory regime so as to accommodate the convergence of new technologies, platforms and services as they develop. The ECA introduced a new licensing regime for infrastructure providers and specifically empowered ICASA to impose pro-competitive regulatory measures on network operators who hold significant market power.

Under the ECA, ICASA is empowered to grant service licenses to both telecommunications and broadcasting service providers. The type of licenses that ICASA may issue are electronic communications network (“ECN”), electronic communications services (“ECS”) and broadcasting licenses. A notable feature of the licensing regime for ECN and ECS is that it is platform, service and technology neutral.

Ownership restrictions 

The ECA imposes a number of statutory restrictions on the ownership and control of broadcasting licensees. However, no similar restrictions are imposed on ECN and ECS licensees in the legislation, although ICASA may publish regulations limiting the ownership or control of an individual licence in order to promote ownership and control by previously disadvantaged individuals and to promote competition in the ICT sector. A foreign national may not, directly or indirectly, exercise control over a commercial broadcasting licensee or have a financial interest or an interest either in voting shares or paid-up capital in a commercial broadcasting licensee, exceeding 20%. Furthermore, no more than 20% of the directors of a commercial broadcasting licensee may be foreign nationals. The ECA requires ICASA to prescribe broad-based black economic empowerment (“BEE”) shareholding thresholds for applicants for new individual licences, which must be set at a minimum of 30%.

Interception 

Electronic communications networks and systems may be intercepted and monitored under South African law, in accordance with the Regulation of Interception of Communications and Provision of Communication-Related Information Act (“RICA”). RICA essentially seeks to regulate the interception of certain communications and radio frequency spectrums and the provision of certain communications-related information.

In terms of RICA, no person may intentionally intercept or attempt to intercept, or authorise another to intercept, any communication in the course of its occurrence or transmission at any place in South Africa, except where the interception is undertaken under certain circumstances (for example, under the direction of a judge or for law enforcement reasons).

Spectrum Policy 

No person may transmit radio signals in South Africa without a radio frequency spectrum licence. ICASA is empowered by the ECA to control, plan, administer and manage the use and licensing of the radio frequency spectrum. ICASA is also mandated by the ECA to plan for the conversion of analogue uses of the radio frequency spectrum to digital, including the migration to digital broadcasting in its preparation and modification of the radio frequency spectrum plan. The South African government approved the Broadcasting Digital Migration policy in 2008 for the conversion of television broadcasting signals from analogue to digital and has committed to the digital migration of television broadcasting services by 2015.

Technology and e-commerce 

The information technology sector is not heavily regulated in South Africa. However, there are legislative enactments in force that regulate elements of IT such as e-commerce, privacy and data protection and access to information. Information over the Internet is not generally regulated by statute, except in relation to specific areas such as online gambling and child pornography. Common law protections exist in relation to defamatory material that is published online.

Privacy and data protection 

Currently there is no specific legislation that comprehensively governs the protection of personal information in South Africa, although the Protection of Personal Information Bill (“POPI Bill”) will introduce a detailed statutory framework for the processing, retention and destruction of personal data, in line with international best practice. The POPI Bill is not yet law and remains in draft legislation format at this time. It is not clear when the POPI Bill will be enacted, but we anticipate that the Bill will be passed into law during 2013.

Outlook 

The ECA Amendment Bill, published in July 2012, proposes a number of important changes, and signals a significant shift in the regulatory landscape in South Africa. The stated objectives of the ECA Amendment Bill include aligning the ECA with broad-based black economic empowerment, incorporating certain changes relating to ownership and control of commercial broadcasting services, and introducing a Spectrum Management Agency which will have overall responsibility for the management of radio frequency spectrum in South Africa. The provisions of the ECA Amendment Bill will be finalised in due course and it is expected that the amendments, once passed, will have a significant impact on all commercial entities that operate in the ICT sector in South Africa.

In November 2011, ICASA published its high-level framework in respect of local loop unbundling (LLU). The local loop is prescribed as an essential facility, and accordingly, the publication of this framework is regarded as an important development for purposes of increasing competition and ultimately benefitting the consumer. However, to date, details have not yet been released as to precisely how or when the next step in the LLU process will be carried out by ICASA.

These proposed policy and legislative developments should ensure that the ICT sector in South Africa is poised to enter an interesting – and hopefully positive – new phase over the next 12 months.

see more

IT & Telecommunications: South Africa

THE FIRM This three-partner TMT practice has a wide range of sector experience, and represents regulatory body ICASA (Independent Communications Authority of South Africa) as well as numerous operators. Standout mandates include advising MTN, Neotel and Vodacom on contract management in the National Long Distance project for the laying of fibre ducts across South Africa. The team also acted for Ericsson on regional developments, co-ordinating legal counsel across several African jurisdictions.

Sources say: "Bowmans has one of the strongest telecoms teams." "We get good advice and good turnaround times."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Craig Kennedy offers valuable experience in commercial matters. Practice highlights include representing H20 Networks in transactions and government procurement matters.

Public law expert Daniel Pretorius left the team in 2012 to become a history teacher.

THE FIRM This team has considerable expertise in the technology and telecoms sectors, and advises a range of local and pan-African names. Its impressive client roster includes Nedbank and other banking sector clients, which retain the firm in connection with technology service agreements. In telecoms mandates, the team advised ECN Telecommunications on transactional and regulatory issues.

Sources say: "They'll always deliver when it's urgent – they'll go out of their way and the quality of work is really superb." "They're responsive and alert to the issues – including some we hadn't thought of."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Clients praise Preeta Bhagattjee's tenacity and the quality of her customer service. She is known for both IT and outsourcing work, and acts for an impressive roster of clients.

Kathleen Rice is a prominent telecoms regulatory lawyer. She leads the firm's work for ECN and other high-profile clients in this sector.

Peers have very high regard for Clem Daniel's extensive industry experience, and clients commend his ability to "pull together IT knowledge and the ability to draft well with absolute willingness."

THE FIRM This growing department has gained two further lawyers through lateral hires, and offers a wide range of experience in IT and telecoms work. In-depth knowledge of the technology sector is a particular draw for clients, and Hewlett-Packard called on the firm's advice when establishing subsidiaries in ten African countries. The team also handles regional work for telecoms clients, and acted for Seacom on regulatory and contractual issues across several jurisdictions.

Sources say: "They've got very good experience in the ICT market." "Communication is generally very good; I can't fault them for anything."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Rohan Isaacs' expertise in the technology industry earns him high praise from commentators: "He's a genius at what he does – he's really clued-up, knows what he's talking about and is very easy to work with." He is also well known for advice on outsourcing matters.

Since joining the firm in 2011, Bradley Scop has impressed peers and clients with his knowledge of the telecoms sector. Big-ticket work includes advising Reunert on its ZAR188 million acquisition of ECN Telecommunications.

THE FIRM This firm's wide-ranging client base includes a number of high-profile names from the technology sector, as well as corporations seeking the firm's advice on agreements with technology service providers. Internet and e-commerce issues also contribute to its workload, and First National Bank engaged the firm to review its online banking facilities. On the telecoms side, the team represented MTN South Africa in various matters, including an application against the National Consumer Commission. 

Sources say: "A strong IT team."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Robby Coelho is widely recommended as "a very knowledgeable guy," and has advised on a number of major outsourcing agreements of late.

Peter Grealy is valued by clients for his advice on commercial and regulatory issues in the telecoms sector. Highlights include representing FibreCo in the development of a fibre-optic broadband network.

Amanda Armstrong of Werksmans Attorneys has considerable experience in the telecoms and electronic communications arena, and is called on for regulatory advice by clients such as Orbicom.

Future Events 

29th May 2013: GC Seminar, New York Going Mobile: IP and Privacy Considerations

4th June 2013: GC Seminar, Houston Challenges in Creating An Effective and Coordinated Global Compliance Program

9 September 2013: Chambers Latin America Awards 2013, Miami

10 September 2013: Launch of Chambers Latin America 2014, online

3rd October 2013: Chambers Bar Awards 2013, London

22nd May 2014: Chambers USA Awards 2014, New York